REPORTS

OF

CIVIL AND CRIMINAL CASES

DECIDED BY THE

COURT OF APPEALS

OF KENTUCKY

VOLUME XL

By T. R. McBEATH, Reporter

0172672

VOLUME 147 KENTUCKY REPORTS

Containing cases decided from February 16, 1912, to April 23, 1912.

FRANKFORT, KY.:

FRANKFORT PRINTING Co., PRINTERS AND BINDERS

1912

1912

JUDICIAL OFFICERS OF THE STATE

COURT OF APPEALS OF KENTUCKY

(As constituted during the period covered by this volume from

February 16, 1912, to April 23, 1912.)

Ion, J. P. HOBSON, Chief Justice.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES

Hon. JOHN D. CARROLL

Hon. JOHN M. LASSING

Hon. T. J. NUNN

Hon. W. E. SETTLE

Hon. SHACKELFORD MILLER

Hon. ROBERT H. WINN

Hon. WM. ROGERS CLAY, Commissioner,

OFFICERS OF THE COURT

JAMES GARNETT, Attorney General.

JAMES D. BLACK, First Assistant Attorney General,

M. M. LOGAN, Second Assistant Attorney General.

CHARLES H. MORRIS, Third Assistant Attorney General.
T. R. McBEATH, Reporter Court of Appeals.
ROBT, L. GREENE, Clerk Court of Appeals.

COMMONWEALTH ATTORNEYS

Elected November, 1909.

1st District-R. F. SMITH

2nd District-JOHN G. LOVETT

3rd District-DENNY P. SMITH 4th District-JOHN L. GRAYOT 5th District-S. V. DIXON

6th District-BEN D. RINGO
7th District-J. R. MALLORY
8th District-JOHN H. GILLIAM
9th District-J. R. LAYMAN
10th District-F. E. DAUGHERTY

11th District-C. S. HILL
12th District-CHAS. H. SANFORD
13th District-*GEO. D. FLORENCE
14th District-ROBT. B. FRANKLIN
15th District-E. E. WINN

16th District-R. G. WILLIAMS
17th District-W. A. BEAUCHAMP

18th District-JAS. C. DEDMAN
19th District-M. J. HENNESSEY
20th District-J. B. WILHOIT
21st District-W. B. WHITE
22nd District-JOHN R. ALLEN
23rd District-THOS. C. JOHNSON
24th District-JOHN F. BUTLER
25th District-B. A. CRUTCHER
26th District-*J. G. FORRESTER
27th District-J. C. CLOYD
28th District-M. L. JARVIS
29th District-A. A. HUDDLESTON
30th District-JOSEPH HUFFAKER
31st District-W. H. MAY ...

.....