Изображения страниц
PDF
EPUB

1

INTRODUCTION.

Page.

[ocr errors]

61

63

63

II

I 2

APPEARANCE of the hon. Samu-

Page

100

Arguments of Mr. Harper previous to
THE motion that a committee be ap-

the opening of the evidence in
pointed to enquire into the off cial

favor of the respondent

57
con duet of Judge Chase
The motion to insert the name of judge

Evidence on the part of the Respondent.

Peters

The motion to amend

3 Testimony of Samuel Ewing

Appointment of the committee of enquiry

Edward J. Coale

ibid.

Report of the committe

5

Wm. Meredith

Proceedings to frike out Fudge Peters ibid.

Luther Martin

Letter and memorial of Judge Chase ibid.

James Winchester • ibid.

Articles as reported by the committee

9

William Marshall-

64

Report of the articles as amended mak-

David M. Randolph 68

ing eight articles.

John Marshall

69

Articles as agreed on

Appendix

Edmond J. Lee

71

Appointment of Managers

John A. Chevalier ibid.

Message of the Senate with the articles ibid.

Robert Gamble

72

Answer to the fame

ibid,

Philip Gooch

ibid.

David Robertson

73

Wm. Marshall, cross-ex-

amined

94

TRIAL.

Wm. Rawle

95

Edmund J. Lee

96

Gunning Bedford ibid.

Nicholas Vandyke

98

el Chase in the senate

Archibald Hamilton 99

Address to poftpone trial

John Hall

President and members of the fenate .

Samuel P. Moore -

ibid.

sworn

8

John Montgomery

ibid.

Affidavit of judge Chase.

ibid. Mr. Harper's remarks on the teftimo-

Queftion of poltponement to 4th day

ny of and publication of John

of Feb. 1805

IO

Montgomery

Judge Chale's appearance 4th Feb."

Testimony of Wm. H. Winder

Witnelles called over

James Winchester

The arguments of Mr. Randolph on

Thomas Chafe

opening the prosecution

Philip Moore

ibid.

Waiter Dorfey

Evidence on the part of the United

John Purviance

ibid.

States.

Nicholas Brice

ibid.

J. P. Boyd

Testimony of William Lewis

18

Wm. M Mechin

ibid.

Alexander J. Dallas

23

Wm. J. Govane

Edward Tilghman

25

John Campbell

109

William S. Biddle

28

Wm. Cranch

ibid.

William Rawle

29

Thomas Hall

ibid.

George Hay.

33

George Hay

John Taylor

38

David M. Randolph III

John Thompson Mafon

Philip N. Nicholas ibid.

James Triplet

44

John Montgomery ibid.

John Heath,

ibid.

Philip Stewart, in favor

John Ballet

45

of the prosecution

Edmond Randolph

47

George Read

ibid.

James Lea-

49

John Montgomery ibid.

PLEADINGS.

John Thompson Mason

53

Samuel Harrison Smith : 54 Speech of Mr. Early in support of the

John Shephen.

$5

prosecution

104

105

*106

[ocr errors]

236

267

[ocr errors]

MANAGERS FOR THE PROSECUTION.

COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT.

John Randolph, Esq.
Joseph H. Nicholson, Esq.
Cæsar A. Rodney, Esq.

Early, Esq.
Washington Campbell, Esq.

Clarke, Esq.

Joseph Hopkinson, Esq.
Philip B. Key, Esq.
Charles Lee, Esq.
Luther Martin, Esq.
Robert Goodloe Harper, Erg.

DIRECTIONS TO THE BINDER.

Be careful in collating to place a cancel leaf at page 49 ; also at page 172, and
bind up the preface and contents immediately after the title, and before the introduction.
I be opinion of Judge Chase after the lift of the votes.

[merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small]

to wit:

THURSDAY, Yantiary) 5th 1804.

Friday, January 6th, 1804.

The house resumed the confideration of On a motion made and seconded, that

the motion of the fifth instant, "for the the house do come to the following reso. appointment of a committee to enquire lution :

into the official conduct of Samuel Chase,

one of the associate justices of the supreme Resolved, That a committee be appoint: court of the United States,"--and the ed to enquire into the official conduct of said motion, as originally proposed, be. Samuel Chase, one of the associate jufó ing again reâd, in the words following, tices of the supreme court of the United States, and to report their opinion, whe- ir Refolved, That a committee he apther the said Samuel Chase hath so acted poin:ed to enquire into the official conduct in his judicial capacity, as to require the of Samuel Chase, one of the associate interposition of the conftitutional power juftices of the fupreme court of the Uni. of this house:

ted States, and to report their opinion

whether the said Samuel Chase hath so The house proceeded to consider the acted in his judicial capacity, as to require faid motion at the clerk's table: Where. the interposition of the constitutional upon,

power of this house." A motion was made and seconded, thai

A motion was made and seconded, to the farther confideration of the said refo- amend the fame, by inserting after the

words lution be postponed until to-morrow.

one of the affociate justices of

the supreme court of the United States," And debate arising thereon,

the following words, " and of Richard PeAnother motion was made, and the ters, district judge of the district of Penn. question being put, that the house do fylvania." now adjourn,

And on the question, that the house do

agree to the said amendment, It passed in the negative - Yeas 52- It was resolved in the affirmativeNays 62.

Yeas 79-Nays 37.

[ocr errors][ocr errors][merged small]

Willis Alston, junior, Şeth Hafings,

John Rea (of Pennsylvania)
Nathaniel Alexander,
William Hoge,

John Rhea of Tennessee)
Phanuel Bishop,
James Holland,

Jacob Richards,
William Blackledge,
David Holines,

Erastus Root,
John Boyle,
Benjamin Huger,

Thomas Sammons,
Robert Brown,
John G. Jackson,

Thomas Sandford,
Joseph Bryan,
Walter Jones,

Ebenezer Seaver,
William Butler,

William Kennedy, Thompson J. Skinner,
John Campbell,

Nehemiah Knigh', James Sloan,
Joseph Clay,
Michael Leib,

John Smilie,
John Clopton,

Jofeph Lewis, jun. John Smith (of Virginia)
Jacob Crowninthield, Thomas Lowndes,

Richard Stanford,
Richard Cutts,

John B. C. Lucas, Joseph Stanton,
John Dennis,
Andrew M'Cord,

James Stephenson,
William Dickson,
David Meriwether,

John Stewart,
Peter Early,

Nicholas R. Moore, David Thomas,
James Elliot,
Thomas Moore,

Philip R. Thompson,
Ebenezer Elmer,
Jeremiah Morrow,

John Trigg,
John W. Eppes,
Anthony New,

Philip Van Cortlandı,
William Euftis,

Thomas Newton, jun. Isaac Van Horne,
William Findley,

Jofeph H. Nicholson, Joseph B. Varnum,
James Gillespie,
Gideon Olin,

Daniel C. Verplanck,
Edwin Gray,
John Patterson,

Marmaduke Williams,
Andrew Greggi
Oliver. Phelps,

Richard Winn,
Thomas Griffin,

John Randolph, jun. Joseph Winston, and
John A. Hanna,
Thomas M. Randolph,

Thomas Wynns. -794
Josiah Hasbrouck,

Those who voted in the negative are,
Simeon Baldwin,
David Hough,

John Cotton Smith,
David Bard,
Samuel Hunt,

John Smith, (of N. York)
George Michael Bedinger, Thomas Lewis,

Henry Southard,
Silas Betton,
Henry W. Livingstong

Samuel Taggart,
Adam Boyd,

William M'Creery, Samuel Tenny,
William Chamberlin, Nahum Mitchell,

Samuel Thatcher,
Martin Chittenden, Samuel L. Mitcbill, ito George Tibbits,
Clifton Claggett,
James Mott,

Abrain Trigg,
Manaffel Cutler,
Bariah Palmer,

Killian K. Van Rensselaer,
Samuel W. Dana,
Thomas Plater,

Peleg Wadsworth,
John Davenport,

Samuel D. Purviance, John Whitehill, and
Gaylord Griswold, Joshua Sands,

Lemuel Williams.- 374
Roger Griswold,

« ПредыдущаяПродолжить »